|
Reader, “We” started a war, gas prices are rising, home sales are stagnant, AI-fear is rampant with new college graduates, immigration has all but stopped, farmers are hurting, and on, and on. And the stock market keeps rising. What’s going on? Let's think about the past, the present, and the future. The Past: We’ve Seen This Movie BeforeIn the late 1990s, investors poured money into internet companies with little more than a name and a promise. Profits didn’t matter. Cash flow didn’t matter. What mattered was growth, “eyeballs,” and the belief that “this time is different.” Then came 2000. The dot-com bubble burst. Trillions of dollars in market value evaporated. Companies disappeared overnight. Investors who had chased momentum were left holding losses they didn’t understand. The lesson was obvious: Valuations must eventually connect to reality. But eight years later, we watched it happen again. In the mid-2000s, the housing market became the new engine of irrational confidence. Home prices would “always go up.” Risk was “managed” through financial engineering. Mortgage-backed securities were labeled safe. Leverage expanded quietly, then rapidly. Then came 2008. The financial system cracked. Institutions failed. Governments intervened. The global economy stalled. Again, the lesson was obvious: Leverage, opacity, and misplaced confidence create systemic risk. And yet… Here we are again. Different assets. Different language. Same pattern. A Pattern: Bubbles Don’t Start with IgnoranceThey start with partial learning. Each bubble is built on something real:
The problem arises when people extrapolate trends without discipline, meaning they project current patterns into the future without considering limits or supporting evidence. Leaders and investors begin to:
Going back to my 2006 book The Prepared Mind of a Leader, I see this as a failure across multiple Prepared Mind skills:
The Present: Are We Learning Now?Let’s bring this into today’s environment. We are watching massive investment flow into areas like:
And once again, the language sounds familiar:
To be clear, some of these claims are true. But that’s exactly what makes bubbles dangerous. They are never built on nonsense. They are built on truth taken too far. The Deeper Issue: Why We Don’t LearnIf the lessons are so clear, why do we repeat the same mistakes? Because learning from the past is not just analytical, it’s behavioral. Three forces are working against us: 1. Recency Bias We overweight what’s happening now and underweight what has happened before. 2. Social Reinforcement When everyone believes the same thing, it feels safe even when it’s wrong. 3. Incentive Structures Short-term gains are rewarded. Long-term discipline is often ignored. In other words, the system rewards participation in the bubble more than resistance to it. Until it doesn’t. The Future: Intercepting the Next BubbleYou cannot eliminate bubbles, but you can intercept their impact. Go back to the Prepared Mind skills identified above: 1. Strengthen Observation and watch for signals of excess:
2. Upgrade Reasoning and ask:
3. Institutionalize Challenge and create space for dissent:
4. Practice real Reflection and learn from past bubbles.
Final ThoughtFinancial bubbles are recurring features of human systems. This means the real differentiator is not prediction, it’s preparation. That's one of the reasons we've created The Prepared Mind Project. Three Questions for This WeekLearn from the Past: Deal with the Present: Intercept the Future: “The book”A draft of Navigating the Wicked World has been reviewed by eight beta readers and updated. Next step is finding a line-editor. Stay tuned. I hope you have a great week. Bill |
Four careers over 50+ years. USMC, engineering, consulting, education. Past twenty years have focused on helping leaders become and remain relevant during times of change.
Reader, My beta readers for Navigating a Wicked World have given me plenty of solid feedback, so I’m busy with “the book.” This week’s Reflection is short and sweet (I hope). Many of you know that I use the example of a radar screen in my workshops and ask participants to consider what’s on the edge. Here are a few things that I’ve noticed this week and want to bring to your attention. Remember 2008? Mortgage and banking systems got in a lot of trouble due to their “financial engineering.”...
Reader, Here are a few stories from yesterday and today that may apply to tomorrow. Me and my slide rule After my “military sabbatical” in the mid-1960s I returned to the college campus to finish my education. I decided to study engineering and was on campus when TI, Casio, and HP introduced calculators. A big question at the time was “Is using a calculator rather than a slide rule a form of cheating?” Well, no. But yes. Regarding exams, it was simply a tool that made precisions calculations...
Reader, I was on a call Friday with a financial analyst, and we spent a bit of time wondering about the similarities of the 1929 Market Crash and the probability of a recession in 2026. Certainly, the specifics are different, but are there some similarities? Yes. That conversation got me thinking about bad and good surprises over the last 100 years that, just maybe, should not have been so surprising. Here are a few for your consideration. Stories of Surprises 1929 Market Crash: A LOT of...