Reader,

Have you ever seen decisions that seemed like a great idea at the time—only to see them backfire later? For example, the widespread use of antibiotics saved millions of lives, but overuse led to antibiotic-resistant bacteria, making some infections harder to treat. Or maybe you held on to your bestselling product for too long and you became irrelevant (Kodak).

These are examples of unintended consequences—the hidden, second- and third-order effects of decisions that only become obvious after the fact.

The good news? While we can’t eliminate unintended consequences completely, we can learn to anticipate and mitigate them. By applying systems thinking and critical foresight techniques, you can make better, more resilient decisions.

The Law of Unintended Consequences

The Law of Unintended Consequences states that every action has effects beyond what we originally intended. These effects can be:

• Positive: A tech company builds a flexible remote work policy to cut costs, but it also attracts top talent globally.
• Negative: A business automates customer service to save money, but customers leave due to poor support.
• Perverse: A policy designed to improve profitability actually creates new problems (e.g. Lower credit limits result in lower-quality mortgages, which subsequently lead to loan defaults).

Most leaders focus on first-order effects—the immediate and obvious results of a decision. But the real risks (and opportunities) lie in the second- and third-order effects—the proverbial “ripple effects” that emerge over time.

Why We Fall into the Trap

There are several reasons why people fail to anticipate unintended consequences. Here are three:

1. Short-Term Thinking

Many decisions are made with a focus on immediate gains rather than long-term sustainability. For example:

• Offering steep discounts may drive short-term revenue but train customers to only buy on sale in the long run. JC Penny fell into this trap.
• Firing employees to cut costs might improve “efficiency,” but reduce institutional knowledge and productivity over time. The current DOGE efforts are about to experience this.

2. Over-Simplification

Business leaders often make decisions assuming if X happens, Y will follow. But business systems are filled with interdependencies.

• A company that reduces customer service hours to save money might think it’s a simple tradeoff. If customer satisfaction drops, complaints and refunds increase, leading to higher long-term costs.

3. Ignoring Feedback Loops

Every business operates within a system of feedback loops—where one decision influences others, sometimes in unpredictable ways.

• A company outsources manufacturing to China to lower costs but ends up with longer supply chains and product delays. This frustrates customers, leading to lost sales and reputational damage. We saw this “big time” during the Covid-19 years.

How to Anticipate and Reduce Unintended Consequences

Instead of reacting to unintended consequences after they happen, smart leaders work to anticipate them in advance. Here are three suggestions

1. Think in Second- and Third-Order Effects

When deciding, don’t just ask “What will happen?” Instead, ask:

• “What happens next?” (Second-order effect)
• “What happens after that?” (Third-order effect)

For example:

• First-Order Thinking: Lower prices to attract more customers.
• Second-Order Thinking: More customers mean higher demand on inventory and customer service.
• Third-Order Thinking: If we can’t meet demand, customers will have a bad experience and leave.

2. Use a “Pre-Mortem” Analysis

A pre-mortem is the opposite of a post-mortem—instead of analyzing failure after it happens, you imagine your decision has already failed and ask: “Why did this go wrong? What unintended consequences did we miss?”

Example: Before launching a new product, a company might ask:

• What if it’s too successful? (Can we scale production?)
• What if it fails? (Do we have a backup strategy?)

3. Learn from Others’ Mistakes

Many unintended consequences are predictable because they’ve happened before.

• Kodak ignored digital photography’s second-order effects and lost its market.
• McDonald’s introduced “Super Size” portions in the 1990s to increase revenue and provide more value to customers. However, this was seen as contributing to the obesity epidemic, attracting negative media attention.

Studying how other businesses miscalculated ripple effects can help avoid repeating the same mistakes.

Conclusion: Think Beyond the Obvious

Good thinkers don’t just focus on an immediate outcome, they think in layers, time horizons, and ripple effects.

Before making an important personal or business decision, ask:

• What happens next, and what happens after that?
• What unintended consequences could arise?
• How can we prepare for them now, instead of reacting later?

What’s an unintended consequence you’ve faced in your business? How did you handle it and what did you learn?

Advanced Notice

We are going to grow our email list with a multi-week LinkedIn campaign and will be offering a lead magnet (i.e., a freebie checklist) to get people to give us their email address. I don’t want you to feel neglected so I will send the checklist in a few days.

Cheers,

Bill